When Your Aircraft Appraisal Comes In Low: What Borrowers Can Do

When an aircraft appraisal comes in below the purchase price, many lenders size the loan on the lower of the two numbers, so the gap usually shows up as more cash at closing or new terms, not an automatic decline. Your options are to bring more cash, renegotiate the price, correct records or condition issues, ask your lender about its review process, or get an independent second opinion your lender will accept.

That is the short answer. Lender practice varies, so confirm with your lender exactly how it sizes your loan. RAD Jets provides independent USPAP appraisals of business jets and turboprops for lender files, and we are glad to explain what drove a value.

What a low appraisal means

An appraisal is an independent opinion of value as of a specific date, for a specific intended use. It is not a price target, and it is not a verdict on whether you negotiated well.

Lenders compare the appraised value to the purchase price when they set the loan to value (LTV). For more on how lenders use an appraisal, see our page on USPAP aircraft appraisals for banks and lenders.

A value under the contract price is common in a moving market. It does not mean the seller, the broker, or the appraiser made a mistake. It means the evidence on the effective date pointed to a different number than the deal did.

What happens if my aircraft appraisal comes in below the purchase price?

Many lenders base the loan on the lower of purchase price or appraised value, so the loan amount may shrink and you cover the difference with cash or new terms. A low value rarely ends a deal by itself. Ask your lender exactly how it sizes the loan.

Why appraisals come in low

Most low values trace back to a handful of drivers.

What causes an aircraft appraisal to come in low?

Common drivers are incomplete records, damage history, engine time or program status, condition, upcoming maintenance, and closed sales that sit below asking prices. A dated effective date in a falling market can also matter. Prepare complete records before ordering to avoid surprises.

Your options as a borrower

You have more room than it may feel like on the day the number arrives.

  1. Bring more cash. Cover the gap between the price and the lending basis. Ask your lender how it sizes the loan before you decide how much.
  2. Renegotiate the price. An independent value gives you a documented basis to ask the seller to revisit price. Your broker or counsel should lead that conversation. See pre-purchase and sale aircraft appraisals.
  3. Fix records or condition issues. If a missing record or a condition item drove the value, address it, then ask whether an update is appropriate. Factual errors, such as wrong times or missing equipment, can be corrected. Preferences cannot.
  4. Ask your lender about its review process. Many lenders have their own way of handling questions on an appraisal. Appraisal review under USPAP (Standard 3) is a separate assignment that assesses the quality of another appraiser's work. Your lender handles that process. RAD Jets does not perform appraisal review.
  5. Get an independent second opinion, if your lender will accept it. RAD Jets takes second-opinion engagements when another appraiser's lender value came in low. Confirm first which credentials your lender accepts and who engages the work.

None of these options is advice for your specific deal. Talk with your lender and your counsel before you choose a path.

Can I renegotiate the price after a low appraisal?

Often, yes. An independent value gives the buyer a documented basis to ask the seller to revisit price. Whether and how to do it depends on your purchase agreement, so involve your broker or counsel. The appraisal states value. It does not tell either party what to accept.

What is an appraisal review?

Appraisal review is a separate USPAP assignment (Standard 3) in which a qualified reviewer assesses the quality of another appraiser's work. Lenders often have their own review process. A review is not an automatic new value. Ask your lender how it handles questions on a report.

Should I get a second opinion appraisal?

Possibly, if your lender will accept it. Confirm first which appraisers and credentials the lender accepts and who engages the work. A second opinion is an independent appraisal of the same aircraft. It may land higher, lower or the same.

What an appraiser can and cannot do

An appraiser can explain the scope of the work, correct factual errors, consider new information you provide, and update a report when corrected or new facts come in. When RAD Jets receives corrected facts on one of our own reports, we update that report. That is a correction of facts, not a move toward a target number.

An appraiser cannot work toward a target number, and pay cannot depend on reaching a particular value. USPAP prohibits both. RAD Jets never promises a higher value, on a first appraisal or a second opinion.

Can the appraiser change the value?

An appraiser can correct factual errors, such as wrong times or a missing equipment item, and can consider new information. Under USPAP an appraiser cannot work toward a target number or have pay tied to a result. A changed value needs evidence, not preference.

How to avoid a surprise next time

For an overview of our services, visit the aircraft appraisals page.

About Chris Canon, MBA, ASA

Chris Canon, MBA, ASA owns and operates RAD Jets. He is an Accredited Senior Appraiser with the American Society of Appraisers, with over 15 years of industry experience including more than 12 with Textron Aviation across airframe, avionics, and full aircraft operations. The practice focuses on USPAP-compliant desktop and on-site appraisals for business jets and turboprops.

Talk through a low appraisal

Start with a free preliminary call. We will look at what you have and talk through whether a second opinion or an update fits your situation. Turnaround is very fast.

When you reach out, share the aircraft make and model, the purchase price, the appraised value and its effective date, your lender, and your target closing date.

Email chris@radjets.com or call 770-316-1631. More at radjets.com.

Disclaimer

This page is an educational overview of options after a low aircraft appraisal. It is not legal, credit, financial, or tax advice. Loan terms are set by your lender, and purchase terms by your agreement. Talk with your lender and counsel about your deal.